Skip to main content

m11 · The EP study: catheters, pacing protocols, intervals, entrainment

Warning

Education only. Not for diagnosis, treatment or any clinical decision.

In 60 seconds

An electrophysiology (EP) study records electrograms from a few catheters inside the heart and paces from them. A catheter at the His bundle splits atrioventricular (AV) conduction into the AH interval, through the AV node, and the HV interval, through the His–Purkinje system. Pacing protocols probe the tissue: premature beats after a train (S1–S2) trace recovery curves and find refractory periods; incremental pacing shortens the cycle length until conduction fails, and the AV node fails gradually, lengthening its conduction time beat by beat until a beat blocks (Wenckebach periodicity). During a reentrant tachycardia, pacing slightly faster than the tachycardia captures the circuit without stopping it: entrainment. When pacing stops, the time to the next local beat, the post-pacing interval (PPI), tells how far the pacing site is from the circuit. These measurements are what a mapping system annotates, and they are simple enough to model.

From the field

  • The His recording started it. Scherlag and colleagues described a catheter technique for recording His-bundle activity in man (Scherlag et al. 1969), the basis of AH and HV measurement.
  • The AV node slows before it blocks. In rabbit preparations the anterograde nodal conduction time ranged from a minimum of 57 ± 2 ms to a maximum of 150 ± 13 ms, with a nodal effective refractory period of 91 ± 10 ms (Reid et al. 2003). With these values, a recovery-curve model gives 1:1 conduction down to 241 ms, then 4:3 at 220 ms and 2:1 at 150 ms (lab part C).
  • Entrainment finds circuit sites. After myocardial infarction, radiofrequency current terminated ventricular tachycardia more often where the post-pacing interval approximated the tachycardia cycle length (odds ratio 4.6) or entrainment showed concealed fusion (odds ratio 3.4) (Stevenson et al. 1993).
  • Not every site with concealed fusion is in the circuit. In the same study, PPI and stimulus-to-QRS analysis suggested that 25% of sites with concealed fusion were bystanders (Stevenson et al. 1993).

Derivations

Symbols used throughout. \(t_A\), \(t_H\), \(t_V\) local activation times of the atrial, His and ventricular deflections (ms); AH, HV intervals (ms). NCT nodal conduction time; RT recovery time since the node last conducted; \(\text{ERP}_N\) nodal effective refractory period; \(\text{NCT}_{\min}\), \(\text{NCT}_{\max}\) its limits; \(\tau\) recovery time constant; CL pacing cycle length (ms). TCL tachycardia cycle length; PPI post-pacing interval (ms); \(d\) distance from the pacing site to the circuit (mm); CV conduction velocity along that path (mm/ms = m/s).

Intervals

A catheter at the His bundle records three deflections each beat: atrial, His and ventricular. With local activation times taken at the steepest downslope of each (m22):

\[ \text{AH} = t_H - t_A, \qquad \text{HV} = t_V - t_H \tag{1}\]

AH is dominated by conduction through the AV node and HV by conduction through the His–Purkinje system, so the two locate delay or block along the AV axis; it is the His-bundle recording (Scherlag et al. 1969) that makes the split possible. On a synthetic recording with noise, the steepest-slope times give both intervals within 0.2 ms (lab part A). Real recordings need care with far-field signals and with a His deflection that is small next to atrial and ventricular ones.

Key takeaways

  • AH measures nodal conduction; HV measures His–Purkinje conduction.
  • Both depend on how local activation time is defined on each deflection.

The AV nodal recovery curve

The AV node conducts more slowly when it has had less time to recover since it last conducted. A recovery curve describes this:

\[ \text{NCT}(\text{RT}) = \text{NCT}_{\min} + (\text{NCT}_{\max} - \text{NCT}_{\min})\,e^{-(\text{RT} - \text{ERP}_N)/\tau}, \qquad \text{RT} \ge \text{ERP}_N \tag{2}\]

Below \(\text{ERP}_N\) the node blocks. Premature atrial beats after a steady train measure the curve point by point; the longest coupling interval that blocks gives \(\text{ERP}_N\). We use the rabbit anterograde values above (Reid et al. 2003) with an illustrative \(\tau\) = 100 ms. Billette’s group showed that a blocked beat can still reset the node’s excitability, concealed conduction (Xu et al. 2006), which this one-variable model ignores.

Wenckebach periodicity

With atrial pacing at a fixed cycle length, each beat’s recovery time is the cycle length minus the previous beat’s nodal conduction time, \(\text{RT}_n = \text{CL} - \text{NCT}_{n-1}\). A long conduction time leaves less recovery for the next beat. The steady 1:1 state needs \(\text{RT} \ge \text{ERP}_N\), so

\[ \text{CL}_W = \text{ERP}_N + \text{NCT}_{\max}, \qquad \text{stable if } \frac{\text{NCT}_{\max} - \text{NCT}_{\min}}{\tau} < 1 \tag{3}\]

is the shortest cycle length with 1:1 conduction: 241 ms here, where the slope condition gives 0.93. Below \(\text{CL}_W\) conduction times lengthen beat by beat until one beat blocks, the node recovers, and the cycle repeats: 8:7 at 235 ms, 4:3 at 220 ms, 3:2 at 200 ms and 2:1 at 150 ms (lab part C). If the slope condition fails, the 1:1 state loses stability before \(\text{CL}_W\).

Exact

Assumptions

  • Model: Equation 2 and Equation 3, iterated beat by beat; recovery time counted from the last conducted beat. Tested against epml.epstudy.
  • Parameters: \(\text{NCT}_{\min}\) = 57 ms, \(\text{NCT}_{\max}\) = 150 ms and \(\text{ERP}_N\) = 91 ms from rabbit preparations (Reid et al. 2003); \(\tau\) = 100 ms is illustrative.
  • What it ignores: dual nodal pathways, concealed conduction (Xu et al. 2006), autonomic tone, fatigue and human values.

Key takeaways

  • The AV node’s recovery curve turns incremental pacing into Wenckebach periodicity.
  • The Wenckebach point is the refractory period plus the longest conduction time, if the 1:1 state is stable.

Entrainment and the post-pacing interval

Pacing slightly faster than a reentrant tachycardia sends an orthodromic wave into the circuit that resets it to the pacing rate, while the antidromic wave collides with the previous beat; when pacing stops the tachycardia continues (Waldo 1997). After the last stimulus, the paced wave travels a distance \(d\) to the circuit, goes once around and returns, so:

\[ \text{PPI} - \text{TCL} \approx \frac{2d}{\text{CV}}, \qquad \text{PPI} \approx \text{TCL} \text{ on the circuit} \tag{4}\]

In simulations, Stevenson and colleagues showed that the PPI equals the tachycardia cycle length at circuit sites and always exceeds it at bystander sites, and that slowing in the circuit during pacing lengthens the PPI (Stevenson et al. 1993). In a Mitchell–Schaeffer ring with a dead-end branch, PPI − TCL was 12 ms on the circuit, 83 ms at 10 mm and 148 ms at 20 mm, against 2d/CV = 72 and 148 ms; pacing 60 instead of 20 ms faster raised the on-circuit value from 12 to 38 ms (lab parts D and E).

Exact

Assumptions

  • Model: Equation 4 for a pacing site connected to the circuit by a path of length \(d\) with uniform velocity. Tested against epml.epstudy.
  • Parameters: distance and velocity are free choices for illustration.
  • What it ignores: slowing during pacing (lab part E), decremental conduction, and the difference between stimulus and local activation at the pacing site.

Key takeaways

  • PPI minus TCL is the round trip from the pacing site to the circuit.
  • Rate-related slowing adds to it, so pace only slightly faster than the tachycardia.

Clinical correlate

NotePending clinical review

This section describes published findings only. It is not guidance for patient care, and it has not yet been reviewed by an EP physician.

Where this shows up in EP. Catheter recording of His-bundle activity (Scherlag et al. 1969) is what separates AH from HV. Recovery-curve studies in animal preparations describe the AV node’s slow and fast pathways and concealed conduction (Reid et al. 2003; Xu et al. 2006). Entrainment was first described during pacing of atrial flutter and is used to identify mapping sites within or outside a reentrant circuit (Waldo 1997). In 15 patients with ventricular tachycardia late after myocardial infarction, radiofrequency current terminated tachycardia at 24 of 241 sites (10%); termination was more likely where the PPI approximated the tachycardia cycle length, where entrainment showed concealed fusion, or where the stimulus-to-QRS interval was more than 60 ms and less than 70% of the cycle length (Stevenson et al. 1993). Mapping systems display these timings; the physiology above is how they are read.

What the evidence is. A technique report (Scherlag et al. 1969), animal preparations (Reid et al. 2003; Xu et al. 2006), a review (Waldo 1997) and a combined simulation and clinical study (Stevenson et al. 1993).

What a reader should ask:

  • How was local activation timed on each deflection? Intervals inherit that choice (Equation 1).
  • At what pacing rate was the PPI measured? Faster pacing lengthens it (Equation 4).
  • Was capture of the circuit confirmed? A PPI means nothing without entrainment.

Visual summary

Schematic

AHV AHHV intervals on the His recording ✕ AV Wenckebach: longer, longer, block PPI − TCL ≈ 2d / CV
Figure 1: Intervals, Wenckebach periodicity and the post-pacing interval.

Assumptions

How experts think

When reading an EP study, ask:

  1. Where is the delay? AH or HV (Equation 1).
  2. Is AV conduction behaving like a node? Decremental, with Wenckebach periodicity at fast rates (Equation 3).
  3. What was the pacing protocol? Train length, coupling intervals and pacing site all change the answer.
  4. Was the circuit entrained, and at what rate? (Equation 4)
  5. Does the PPI agree with the other criteria? Concealed fusion alone can mislead (Stevenson et al. 1993).

One sentence to keep: every number in an EP study is a timing, and every timing depends on how and where it was measured.

Cheat sheet

Quantity Result
Intervals (Equation 1) AH = \(t_H - t_A\) (node); HV = \(t_V - t_H\) (His–Purkinje)
AV nodal recovery (Equation 2) NCT falls from \(\text{NCT}_{\max}\) at \(\text{ERP}_N\) toward \(\text{NCT}_{\min}\)
Wenckebach point (Equation 3) \(\text{CL}_W = \text{ERP}_N + \text{NCT}_{\max}\) if \((\text{NCT}_{\max} - \text{NCT}_{\min})/\tau < 1\)
Post-pacing interval (Equation 4) \(\text{PPI} - \text{TCL} \approx 2d/\text{CV}\); about 0 on the circuit

Values used in this module

Value Source
Rabbit anterograde NCT 57–150 ms, nodal ERP 91 ms Reid et al. (2003)
Odds ratios 4.6 (PPI ≈ TCL) and 3.4 (concealed fusion); 25% bystanders; 24 of 241 sites Stevenson et al. (1993)
Recovery time constant 100 ms; interval times on the synthetic recording illustrative
Conduction ratios, PPI values our own code

Interview questions

Try each question before you open its model answer. In a real interview, say which assumptions you are making.

Q1. What do the AH and HV intervals measure?

Model answer

AH: conduction from the low atrium through the AV node to the His bundle. HV: conduction from the His bundle to the earliest ventricular activation (Equation 1).

Q2. Why is the His deflection hard to time?

Model answer

It is small and sits between large atrial and ventricular deflections; far-field signals and filtering shift the steepest slope (Equation 1; m04, m22).

Q3. What is a recovery curve, and how is it measured?

Model answer

Conduction time against the time since the last conducted beat, measured with premature beats after a steady train; it ends at the effective refractory period (Equation 2).

Q4. Explain Wenckebach periodicity with the recovery curve.

Model answer

Each beat’s recovery time is the cycle length minus the previous conduction time; a longer conduction time shortens the next recovery and lengthens the next conduction time, until recovery falls below the refractory period and a beat blocks (Equation 3).

Q5. With \(\text{ERP}_N\) = 91 ms and \(\text{NCT}_{\max}\) = 150 ms, what is the Wenckebach point?

Model answer

241 ms, if the 1:1 state is stable there (Equation 3).

Q6. What is concealed conduction?

Model answer

A blocked impulse that still enters the node and resets its excitability, so it affects the next beat without being seen (Xu et al. 2006).

Q7. Define entrainment.

Model answer

Capture of a reentrant circuit by pacing slightly faster than the tachycardia, without terminating it; the tachycardia continues when pacing stops (Waldo 1997).

Q8. Why does PPI − TCL estimate distance from the circuit?

Model answer

The last paced wave travels to the circuit, around it and back, so the extra time is the round trip \(2d/\text{CV}\) (Equation 4).

Q9. The PPI is 40 ms longer than the TCL on a site you think is in the circuit. Possible reasons?

Model answer

The site may be outside the circuit; or pacing was too fast and slowed conduction in the circuit; or the post-pacing electrogram was mistimed (Equation 4) (Stevenson et al. 1993).

Q10. What is concealed fusion, and why is it not enough on its own?

Model answer

Entrainment with no change in QRS morphology; it can also occur at bystander sites adjacent to the circuit, so the PPI and stimulus-to-QRS interval are needed too (Stevenson et al. 1993).

Q11. Why pace only slightly faster than the tachycardia when entraining?

Model answer

Faster pacing slows conduction in the circuit and lengthens the PPI, and may terminate or change the tachycardia (Equation 4; lab part E).

Q12. How would you test an automatic PPI calculator?

Model answer

On simulated circuits with known distances and velocities, at several pacing rates and noise levels, checking that it times the local electrogram and not the stimulus artifact (Equation 4).

Code lab

The lab measures, paces and entrains.

Part What you do Data
A AH and HV on a His-bundle recording (Equation 1) synthetic
B The AV nodal recovery curve (Equation 2) published values
C Incremental pacing and Wenckebach periodicity (Equation 3) published values
D Entrainment: post-pacing interval and distance (Equation 4) synthetic
E Pacing rate and the post-pacing interval (Equation 4) synthetic

Each part ends with checks: lines that pass with the code as given. If you change something and a check fails, that is information, not an error to hide.

Self-check

Short checks you can do in your head. Open each answer after you have tried it.

S1. A at 40 ms, H at 125 ms, V at 170 ms. AH and HV?

Answer

85 ms and 45 ms (Equation 1).

S2. With the model of this module, conduction time after a recovery time equal to \(\text{ERP}_N\)?

Answer

\(\text{NCT}_{\max}\) (Equation 2).

S3. Steady 1:1 conduction with NCT = 120 ms at CL 250 ms. Recovery time?

Answer

130 ms (Equation 3).

S4. In a 4:3 Wenckebach pattern, how many atrial beats are blocked per cycle?

Answer

One (Equation 3).

S5. A pacing site 15 mm from the circuit along a path conducting at 0.5 m/s. PPI − TCL?

Answer

60 ms (Equation 4).

S6. PPI − TCL = 0 ms. Where is the pacing site, by this model?

Answer

On the circuit (Equation 4).

Literature figures

These figures are worth looking at alongside this module. We link to them instead of copying them: some licenses do not allow reuse here, and others we could not confirm. Each entry says what to look for and where this module explains it.

  • The His-bundle recording. Scherlag and colleagues show the first catheter recordings of His-bundle activity in man (Scherlag et al. 1969). This module: intervals.
  • Entrainment at circuit and bystander sites. Stevenson and colleagues diagram stimulus-to-QRS and post-pacing intervals in simulated circuits (Stevenson et al. 1993). This module: entrainment.
  • Nodal recovery curves. Reid and colleagues plot anterograde and retrograde recovery curves before and after pathway ablation (Reid et al. 2003). This module: the AV nodal recovery curve.

Further reading

References

Reid, Marie Claude, Jacques Billette, Karim Khalife, and Rafik Tadros. 2003. “Role of Compact Node and Posterior Extension in Direction-Dependent Changes in Atrioventricular Nodal Function in Rabbit.” Journal of Cardiovascular Electrophysiology 14 (12): 1342–50. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.1540-8167.2003.03382.x.
Scherlag, B J, S H Lau, R H Helfant, W D Berkowitz, E Stein, and A N Damato. 1969. “Catheter Technique for Recording His Bundle Activity in Man.” Circulation 39 (1): 13–18. https://doi.org/10.1161/01.cir.39.1.13.
Stevenson, W G, H Khan, P Sager, et al. 1993. “Identification of Reentry Circuit Sites During Catheter Mapping and Radiofrequency Ablation of Ventricular Tachycardia Late After Myocardial Infarction.” Circulation 88 (4 Pt 1): 1647–70. https://doi.org/10.1161/01.cir.88.4.1647.
Waldo, A L. 1997. “Atrial Flutter: Entrainment Characteristics.” Journal of Cardiovascular Electrophysiology 8 (3): 337–52. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-8167.1997.tb00798.x.
Xu, Bochun, Jacques Billette, and Michel Lavallée. 2006. “Concealed Conduction in Nodal Dual Pathways: Depressed Conduction, Prolonged Refractoriness, or Reset Excitability Cycle?” Heart Rhythm 3 (2): 212–21. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.hrthm.2005.11.011.